Portraiture and Baroque

Ritrattistica e Barocco

The evolution of portraiture in painting through the analysis of a work

The genre of portraiture in painting is certainly not an invention of the seventeenth century, nor does it constitute a marked peculiarity of that century, but it is in this century that portraiture, like other genres of painting, attains full artistic dignity, acquiring strong values that had never been fully developed in the past.

The century, as most people know, opens with the dictates set by the new Counter-Reformation Church, premises that will strongly influence the canons of religious art and cut across other art forms.

The early seventeenth century thus marks a clear break with the now-worn and perhaps overly intellectualistic painting of late Mannerism, rigorously logical and demonstrative, often reserved for a few viewers; portraiture itself shines with a true spirit of artistic renewal, imagined with a new, often dramatic and impassioned sensibility.

It would suffice in this regard to mention the portrait of Giovan Carlo Doria on horseback by Rubens preserved at the Spinola Palace in Genoa, or the marble bust of Francesco I d’Este by Bernini housed in the Estense Galleries in Modena.

Portrait of Giovanni Carlo Doria on horseback, Pieter Paul Rubens, oil on canvas, 1606

Bust of Francesco I d’Este, Gian Lorenzo Bernini, marble, 1650 – 1651

Portraiture becomes imbued with all the stylistic and formal demands expressed by the emerging phenomenon of the Baroque, above all the use of rhetoric understood as the art of persuasion, an essential tool for the artist’s communication.
An operating method that fits into the broader and more varied iconographic and iconological context of Baroque art, which seeks to amaze but above all to educate and persuade.

Great aristocratic families begin to rely on the eloquence of portraiture to promote their family name, sometimes with splendor and exuberance like never before. There is a growing awareness of the artwork focused on the broader area of communication; we are at the dawn of the first forms of advertising.

The rhetoric of courtly and celebratory portraiture seems almost to break away from the now obsolete portraiture of the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries, probably more focused on reflecting the psychology of the sitter, “the motions of the soul,” to quote Leonardo da Vinci, in favor here of a representation focused above all on the status of the painted sitter, exalting their role, imposing a sense of authority and prestige, and evoking admiration and awe through the splendor of clothing and the use of particular compositional devices.

Las Meninas, Diego Velazquez, oil on canvas, 1656

Portraiture can often tell, for those who are able to read it, a fleeting reality aimed at concealing social, political, and religious uncertainties, all camouflaged by that innate desire for the ephemeral and stupor mundi typical of the period.

We can find assistance, for a greater understanding of what has been said, in the words of Monsignor Giovan Battista Agucchi who, in his “Treatise on Painting” of 1610, argued that:

“the most evolved form of portraiture was that which, going beyond resemblance to the sitter, depicted the figures as they ought to be, according to their position in the world”

This broad premise about the evolution that runs through the genre of portraiture at the turn of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries serves us well as a preamble to approaching the painting presented here. It is a remarkable work attributed to a painter in the circle of Gian Paolo Cavagna (Bergamo 1550-1627) depicting a portrait of a gentleman with a ruff.

Executed in oil on canvas and featuring a beautiful frame in the style of blackened and gilded wood, it belongs to the collection of antique paintings of the seller Antichità La Pieve.

Portrait of a gentleman with a ruff,
circle of G.P. Cavagna, oil on canvas, first half of the seventeenth century

As in the vast majority of cases, portraits are intrinsically linked to the identity of the sitter, in symbiosis with the culture in which the artist and the sitter are immersed, unlike other portraits that become so anecdotal as to serve merely as a photographic keepsake.

The sitter is framed in this cultural climate in which portraiture found its happy season, a season in which Lombardy was ruled by the Spanish government, from which probably derived the fashion for black clothing (called “Spanish style”). The figure is restrained, cut at three-quarters of its height, magnificent in the way it fully occupies the surrounding space, which is only timidly suggested. The man’s pride is emphasized here not only by his gaze and his upright and imposing pose, but also by the austere and boxy silhouette of his dark clothing, which inspires almost fear and reverence at first sight. A calm and guarded intellectualism is evident in his gaze and continues through to the volume he holds in his right hand.

Portrait of a gentleman with a ruff,
circle of G.P. Cavagna, detail of the face.
The head of the portrait, outlined with clear and decisive brushstrokes, is immersed as if it were a cherry on top, almost hidden by the preciousness of the voluminous ruff.

Portrait of a gentleman with a ruff,
circle of G.P. Cavagna, detail of the left arm. The resting hand, which also allows for an upright and imposing posture, is a sign of awareness of one’s status and a display of confidence.

Precious fabrics, cuts, embroidery, applied trimmings, and other forms of surface ornamentation were the distinctive features of this era, well exemplified in our painting. A curious gilded table clock relegated to the edge of the composition brightens the chromatic temperature of the work, while in his right hand he displays a book, two clear symbolic references evoking the nobleman’s status symbol . A typical ornament of the era was the ruff, which from a modest ornament attached to the neck became a true separate accessory, made of linen, decorated with lace, cutwork, and embroidery, fan-shaped, and supported by iron stays.

The work is finished by the artist filling a good portion of the canvas with a monochrome gray background on which the presence of a column is just barely suggested, a typical learned reference often present in portrait painting.

Portrait of a gentleman with a ruff,
circle of G.P. Cavagna, detail.
The finger inserted into the volume as if it were a bookmark is an unusual detail, just as curious is the shape of the table clock standing on the precious fabric of the table.

Portrait of a gentleman with a ruff,
circle of G.P. Cavagna, detail.
The base part of a Doric semi-column in the background fills and at the same time closes the work to the right of the sitter, a typical learned quotation suited to great parade portraits.

White Gloves by Alessandro Odierna
Online services for antique dealers

T 3893417759
E antiques@outlook.it